Chilmark - 34 Edys Island Way$7,450,000

ID: 42401 Owner: Jensen Available

Zip Code:
02535
Property Type:
Single Family
Total Rooms:
13
Total Bedrooms:
5
Total Bathrooms:
2 full, 1 half
Water Frontage:
Pondfront
Water Views:
Pond
Second Dwelling:
Existing
Zoning:
R3A
Lot Size:
3.80 acres
Total SqFt (ELA):
2,269 sqft
Price/sqft:
$3,283.38
Year Built:
1941
Water / Sewer:
Well / Septic
2025 Assessment:
$3,884,000
Land Assessment:
$3,521,500
Build Assessment:
$362,500
Estimated Taxes:
$8,994.42

Waterfront house and guest house with a private dock on Menemsha Pond. This location is in the heart of Menemsha, a waterfront enclave within walking distance of this classic Harbor. Built and cared for over four generations by an Island legacy family, this property is unique among Island estates for its combination of privacy yet convenience and seclusion yet expansive views. To the Southeast, watch Menemsha Pond ebb and flow around sandy islands with 120 degrees of unobstructed view. To the Northwest, elevated rooms look out over the sunset on Menemsha harbor. A secluded lawn is partially shaded by healthy blue spruce and bordered by an ancient stone wall. To the south, the dock traverses the estuary into a private cove opening up to the main pond and the ocean. A secure environment surrounded by water on three sides. The property is only a short walk to the Menemsha harbor, beach, boutique galleries, and fresh seafood restaurants—from the daily catch from local fish markets to the fine dining of the Home Port. Southern orientation provides sun all-day to both the house and the guest house. Year-round water and new 5-bedroom Title-5 compliant septic. Unique remodeling and expansion options compared with other waterfront Island property due to the existing height, large attic with views, and a lower level with tremendous natural light allowing for valuable future living square footage. You are welcome to continue the legacy of this extraordinary real estate.

Primary Dwelling

Total Rooms:
10
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
1 full, 1 half
Square Feet (ELA):
1,728 sqft

Secondary Dwelling

Total Rooms:
3
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Square Feet (ELA):
541 sqft

Authentic Menemsha guest cottage with exceptional views over Menemsha Pond facing west. Wake up to a front-row view of Menemsha Pond from this one-bedroom cottage fully equipped with a kitchen, living room, and deck sited on Menemsha Pond. Nothing better than this.

First Floor

Beautiful hardwood floors throughout, there is a private den, living room with a fireplace and dining room over looking Menemsha Pond. Kitchen and bath/laundry on main floor.

Second Floor

Four bedrooms most boasting views over Menemsha Pond and beyond which share a full bath. High ceilings and exceptional water views from the second floor.

Third Floor

Large attic which could be incorporated into living space with views over Menemsha Pond, Aquinnah and towards the Ocean.

Basement

Full basement with a walk out which could be a finished lower level. Nice natural sunlight.

Building Information

Furnished:
Un-Furnished
First Floor Beds:
0
Fireplaces:
yes
Floors:
wood floors throughout
Heat:
None
Foundation:
yes full basement
Yard:
manicured, old stonewalls lining the landscape, privacy, expansive views
Parking Description:
yes
Other Buildings:
Garage
Lead Paint:
Unknown

Appliances

Stove:
Electric
Refrigerator:
yes
Dishwasher:
Washer:
yes
Dryer:
yes
TV Service Type:
Cable

Outdoor/Recreation

Beach Access - Public, Deck, Patio, Water Views, Porch

Features

Insulation, Outdoor Shower

Property / Parcel Information

Map:
271
Lot #:
73
Plan:
330
Parcel:
Sub Area:
North
Deed Ref:
1502
Fees:
Fee Frequency:
Fees Include:
Other Views:
Harbor

Open Houses

  • Tuesday, July 1, 2025
    4:00 PM - 5:30 PM
    Refreshments: yes!
    Notes: Please come by to see this iconic property in the heart of Menemsha. I look forward to seeing you!

Documents

Map

©2025 - Listing Information Network, Inc.