Aquinnah - 19 Locust Lane$6,950,000

ID: 44522 Owner: West End Realty Trust / Jay F Theise Trustee Available

Zip Code:
02535
Property Type:
Single Family
Total Rooms:
13
Total Bedrooms:
7
Total Bathrooms:
4 full, 1 half
Water Frontage:
None
Water Views:
Distant Sound
Second Dwelling:
Existing
Zoning:
RES
Lot Size:
16.96 acres
Total SqFt (ELA):
6,921 sqft
Price/sqft:
$1,004.19
Year Built:
2005
Water / Sewer:
Well / Septic
2025 Assessment:
$8,317,900
Land Assessment:
$1,108,100
Build Assessment:
$7,209,800
Estimated Taxes:
$57,140

There is a town at the end of Martha's Vineyard. The road narrows, the houses thin, and the light changes. This is Aquinnah — the westernmost town, clay cliffs, a lighthouse, and one of the smallest year-round populations on the Vineyard. Compound-scale offerings rarely come to market here. 19 Locust Lane is one of them. Nearly 17 acres high above Vineyard Sound, with open water views to the Elizabeth Islands. A custom Dutch Colonial main residence and separate guest house, both built in 2005. Cedar shake. Stone walls. Built to belong to the landscape, not compete with it. Inside: over 6,000 square feet across six bedrooms. Wide-plank floors, an open-plan dining room, and a gourmet kitchen with a Tuscan oven. At its center, a great room with cathedral ceiling, cedar trusses, and a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, facing the ridgeline and water beyond. Room to host, with the flexibility of two living spaces. Aquinnah has kept its character. This is the place that lets you stay there.

 

Primary Dwelling

Total Rooms:
11
Bedrooms:
6
Bathrooms:
3 full, 1 half
Square Feet (ELA):
5,982 sqft

Secondary Dwelling

Total Rooms:
2
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Square Feet (ELA):
939 sqft

3 Bay Garage with a one bedroom apartment on the second floor. Private Porch/Deck with water views

First Floor

Expansive open living room and dining room with soaring ceilings, stone fireplace and sliders to a stone patio. Gourmet fully equipped kitchen with center island and a Tuscan Stone wood burning oven. Cozy nooks for reading or contemplating. Plenty of oversized windows looking out over the meadow to the ocean. Spacious family room that could be used as a bedroom. There is a 1/2 bath and first floor primary bedroom with en-suite bathroom and private patio. Laundry room

Second Floor

There are 4 additional spacious bedrooms, each with water views, that share 2 full bathrooms. A roof deck offers magnificent ocean views.

Basement

Approx 1,000sf unfinished

Other Structures

There is a 3 Car Garage with a one Bedroom Apartment above. Another structure houses a large Kohler Power Systems 80 whole property generator.

Building Information

Furnished:
Un-Furnished
First Floor Beds:
2
Fireplaces:
2
Floors:
Concrete Radiant Heat, Wood, Tile
Heat:
Radiant\hydronic
Foundation:
Poured Concrete
Yard:
Expansive yard and lawn, old stone walls, waterviews of Vineyard Sound
Parking Description:
Circular peastone driveway with abundant guest parking. 3 Bay Garage
Other Buildings:
None
Lead Paint:
No

Appliances

Stove:
6 Burner Viking Gas Cook Top / GE Monogram Double Wall Ovens
Refrigerator:
Separate GE Monogram Refrigerator & GE Monogram Freezer, Wine refrigerator
Dishwasher:
2 - Bosch Dishwashers
Washer:
Whirlpool Duet
Dryer:
Whirlpool Duet
TV Service Type:
Cable

Outdoor/Recreation

Deck, Garden, Patio, Water Views, Porch

Features

Central A/C, Insulation, Irrigation, Outdoor Shower, Wood Stove

Property / Parcel Information

Map:
5
Lot #:
175.1
Plan:
Parcel:
Sub Area:
North
Deed Ref:
914, 861
Fees:
Fee Frequency:
Fees Include:
Other Views:
Pastoral

Directions / Comments

Right on Locust Lane (just passed the Aquinnah town hall and Jeffers Way). Follow until you see driveway on right with wooden sign Theise. Turn right by the sign and follow driveway all the way to the end. Sale includes 5 contiguous parcels totaling +/- 16.96 acres. Photos have been digitally enhanced. Pool and bathroom concepts are digital renders to show potential.

©2026 - Listing Information Network, Inc.